AI Image Generation and the Illustration Industry in Australia

The arrival of AI image generation tools — Midjourney, Adobe Firefly, DALL-E, Stable Diffusion — has prompted significant debate in the illustration industry. For Australian illustrators, understanding what these tools can and cannot do, and how the industry is responding, is practically important.

---

What AI Image Generation Tools Can Do

AI image generation tools can produce images from text prompts. A user can describe an image — style, subject, mood, composition, colour palette — and the tool will generate a visual interpretation of that description. The quality has improved dramatically and can produce images that are visually compelling in many styles.

These tools are trained on large datasets of existing images, which has raised significant copyright concerns. Many illustrators have found their work used in training datasets without consent or compensation, and legal challenges are ongoing in multiple jurisdictions.

---

The Copyright and Training Data Question

The copyright status of AI-generated images and the legality of training AI models on copyrighted images are active legal questions in Australia and internationally.

In Australia, the Copyright Act protects original artistic works. Whether AI-generated images qualify as original artistic works — and who owns the copyright if they do — is not yet settled law. The Australian government has been consulting on AI and copyright reform, and the legal landscape is likely to change.

The training data question is separate: whether it was lawful to train AI models on copyrighted images without consent or compensation is being litigated in multiple jurisdictions. Australian illustrators who believe their work has been used in AI training datasets without consent should seek advice from the Australian Copyright Council or a lawyer with expertise in intellectual property law.

Adobe Firefly is notable in this context because it is trained on licensed content — Adobe Stock images and public domain works — rather than scraped web content. This makes outputs from Adobe Firefly commercially safer from a copyright perspective than outputs from tools trained on unlicensed data.

---

How the Industry Is Responding

Clients are using AI tools. Some clients who previously commissioned illustrations are now using AI tools to generate images instead. This is a real change in the market, particularly for lower-budget editorial and commercial work where the brief is relatively generic.

The demand for distinctive illustration is holding. For work that requires a distinctive visual voice — children's books, brand identity, editorial illustration with a strong point of view — the demand for human illustrators remains strong. AI tools can generate competent generic images; they struggle to generate work with the kind of distinctive personality that makes illustration memorable.

Licensing and usage rights are evolving. Some illustrators are updating their contracts to address AI-related questions — whether clients can use their work to train AI models, whether AI-generated references can be used in briefs, and how AI tools can be used in the production of commissioned work.

---

Practical Implications for Australian Illustrators

Develop a distinctive style. The illustrators who are most insulated from AI competition are those with a distinctive visual voice that is recognisably theirs. Generic illustration in common styles is more vulnerable to AI substitution than work with a strong, personal aesthetic.

Understand the tools. Using AI tools for reference generation, mood board creation, and early concept exploration is becoming common practice. Understanding what these tools can and cannot do — and being able to have an informed conversation with clients about them — is increasingly useful.

Update your contracts. Consider whether your standard contract addresses AI-related questions. The Illustrators Australia organisation has resources for members on contract terms and industry standards.

Stay connected to the industry. The Illustrators Australia organisation and the Australian Copyright Council are both engaged with AI-related questions and have resources for members navigating these issues.

---

What AI Cannot Replace

A distinctive visual voice. The quality that makes great illustration memorable — the particular way an illustrator sees the world and translates it into image — is developed over years of practice and is deeply personal. AI tools can generate images that look like many things; they cannot generate images that look like you.

The relationship with the client. Commissioned illustration involves a relationship between the illustrator and the client — understanding what the client needs, developing concepts together, and refining the work through feedback. This relationship is a significant part of the value that illustrators provide.

Cultural specificity. Australian illustration has a distinctive cultural context — the landscape, the light, the stories, the visual references. AI tools trained primarily on international datasets may struggle to produce work that feels authentically Australian.

Where to Get Support and Information

Australian illustrators navigating AI-related questions have several resources available:

Illustrators Australia (illustratorsaustralia.com) is the peak body for illustrators in Australia. It has been engaged with AI-related questions and has resources for members on contracts, copyright, and industry standards.

The Australian Copyright Council (copyright.org.au) provides free information and advice on copyright law in Australia, including AI-related questions. It also offers paid legal advice for more complex situations.

The Australian Society of Authors (asauthors.org) represents authors and illustrators and has been active on AI and copyright issues, including submissions to government consultations on AI and copyright reform.

Staying connected to these organisations and following their communications on AI-related developments is the most reliable way to stay informed as the legal and industry landscape continues to evolve.